geometrical border

The Paradox of Limiting a Business Owner's Duty to Keep Its Customers Safe

May 9, 2024

This article was first published in the Detroit Legal News on May 9, 2024.

A. Vince Colella

Moss & Colella P.C.

In the recent wake of our Supreme Court’s reversal of Lugo v Ameritech resulting in the eradication of the “open and obvious” defense to premise liability cases, a look back at another decision issued within a week of Lugo bears attention and appellate re-examination. On July 3, 2001, Chief Justice Robert Young authored the opinion in MacDonald v PKT, Inc. The case involved a group of concertgoers attending a rock concert at Pine Knob who began to pull sod from the lawn seating area and hurl it at other attendees of the show. Unfortunately, Molly MacDonald fractured her ankle while trying to avoid being struck by a piece of sod.

Until that time, the law in Michigan was clear: business owners had a duty to reasonably respond to situations occurring on their premises that pose a risk of imminent and foreseeable harm to its identifiable invitees, or simply stated, its guests. However, this duty did not require business owners to provide private security or resort to “self-help” to deter or quell potentially violent occurrences between customers of their establishments. The law at the time recognized that businesses, including restaurants, bars, and concert venues, had no obligation to anticipate and prevent criminal acts against their customers. The prevailing thought behind the law was that crime, by its nature, is random and unforeseeable. A notion that was debunked by statistical crime data suggesting that violent crimes typically involve individuals who are known (or related) to each other. Therefore, businesses were not expected to provide protection unless a situation was occurring on their property that would alert a “reasonable” owner to the potential violence that may befall their guest. A seemingly fair approach.

However, paradoxically, in his analysis of the line of cases that pre-dated MacDonald, Chief Justice Young was quick to emphasize that under no circumstances did the duty to keep customers safe carry an obligation to provide “police protection.”  The Court rationalized, “…even police, who are specially trained and equipped to anticipate and deal with crime, are unfortunately unable universally to prevent it.” However, the MacDonald opinion has had the opposite effect of its intended purpose. Rather than absolving business owners of the duty to provide police protection, it now requires it.

From a practical perspective, a claim of “failure to expedite” (the ostensible legal cause of action that grew out of the MacDonald decision) invokes a responsibility of businesses to invoke police involvement into private security matters within its establishment — thus shifting the economic burden of safeguarding a business to the taxpayer. Commercial businesses under the MacDonald decision are required to expedite the police when they “know or should know” that the danger of violence is afoot. Consequently, the expense of protecting “business invitees” (the customers for whom they profit) has been imputed upon the police and essentially on the public.

Looking back at the line of cases that pre-date MacDonald, it is hard to debate that the legal (and economic) tort principles borne out of the “common law,” and universally adopted by most states since the early 1900s, provide a more reasoned framework for analyzing the so-called “merchant’s liability.” Perhaps, more importantly, it just makes more sense. In Royal v Mason Dequindre, a Michigan Supreme Court consolidated opinion released on the precipice of a succession of “conservative” judicial appointments, and the Supreme Court determined that a bar owner’s duty to protect its guests from assaults by other patrons shouldn’t be narrowly construed. Rather, the Court was persuaded that the 2nd Restatement of Torts provided more sound guidance in determining the duty of businesses to protect their guests. The majority opinion emphasized the context in which these cases should be decided and reiterated a common law principle, stating, “…if the place or character of his business, or his past experience, is such that he should reasonably anticipate careless or criminal conduct on the part of third persons, either generally or at some particular time, he may be under a duty to take precautions against it, and to provide a reasonably sufficient number of servants to afford a reasonable protection.” [Comment F, Restatement of Torts 2d, §344]  

Unquestionably, business owners who are most familiar with their customers’ attitudes, behaviors and propensities are in a much better position to warn other customers, implement safeguards to protect against foreseeable violence, and deter potential perpetrators more so than the police (who are tasked with the unenviable responsibility of protecting an entire community). Moreover, the expectation that a police department could be alerted to a potential disturbance within a bar or restaurant, and dispatch a police officer to investigate the situation before a violent situation erupts is naïve at best.  

Expanding the duty to protect customers beyond simply expediting the police will shift the economic burden back to the business owners, and in turn, make their establishments safer.

—————

A.Vince Colella is a founding partner of Southfield-based personal injury and civil rights law firm Moss & Colella.  

No items found.

Client Testimonials

I HIGHLY recommend David Moss; he exceeded my expectations numerous times, and I feel fortunate and blessed to have worked with him and his team. Moss & Colella attorneys have relentless perseverance and dedication for everyone they represent.
If this firm takes your case, it's in exceptionally experienced hands. The hands of attorneys who care about your well-being and the outcome of your litigation!
When I got into a car accident, my life changed. David and Ryan understood how this change affected my livelihood and mobility. They handled my case professionally, and I couldn't be more thankful for all of the sincere guidance and help provided throughout this process.
Thanks so much for everything!!!

The Burls

Client

 I was referred to Moss & Colella in 2018 following a car accident. I cannot tell you how confident and safe I felt knowing that I was in good hands. David, and Ryan made sure that I always had any questions or concerns addressed in a timely manner. I appreciated their compassion, and understanding as I got emotional, and the reassurance they provided, made me feel important and valued as a client. If you need a great lawyer for an injury, this is your firm! I hope I never need to be in a position where I’d need their help again, but if I did, I’d gladly seek their services!

T. Ray

Client

My son sadly passed after a vehicle accident, it was a hard case. Mr. Moss was our lawyer, he was very helpful, very informative, very up front and put alot of effort into this case. He’s a great man, a honest man and his law firm will do the best with any case brought to them. Everyone at his office was very kind and very helpful. I absolutely recommend them for any of your lawsuit needs.
Very grateful for this firm!

S. Collins

Client

Words can not express how grateful I am for the outcome of this case. It was truly a blessing to have this resolved sooner than expected. But without your help and my faith in your firm along with my faith on God, this may not have been possible. I appreciate everything you have done in orchestrating everything to this resolve, for your time and effort meant the world to me. I thank my friend for putting me in touch with such a talented group of people. You will always be considered my attorneys of choice for anything that comes up in the future that would render your services. This year has definitely been many blessings so far and I welcome many more to come. Thank you again for everything and may you continue to be blessed.

Janene

Mother of Client

Very few people on this earth impress me. You are one of the very few. My family and I thank you for all you did. You are a good man!

Jason

Client

Other law firms would not take my case, they said it was too complicated. But David Moss took my case and got the result I was looking for in almost no time at all. I’m glad I didn’t listen to those other lawyers.

Anonymous

Client

I just wanted to thank you for putting your time and effort into my case. You did a wonderful job last Thursday. You are what people say you are, a wonderful lawyer.

Adam

Client

I do not only count on you as one bad ass lawyer, but also a friend. None of this would be possible without you. My deepest gratitude to you and all of the Moss & Colella team.

Anonymous

Client

I am very relieved and very happy with the outcome. I appreciate everything you and your firm did to see this through and I will be grateful for that always. You all came highly recommended and now I see why based on what you did in helping my son through a very challenging moment in his life. We will always be your fans:) Thank you again and may you always be Blessed…

Anonymous

Mother of Client

Moss & Colella PC goes above and beyond, and then some, to get the results you need and deserve! Since my accident in 2021, in which I broke several bones and am not able to work anymore, my vehicle insurance company dropped the ball. They not only tried to discredit me, but also have been trying to screw me out of what was owed to me. Thank you to David and the whole team for putting their all into my case, I got more than I expected! I am so overwhelmed and appreciative by what they have done for me!

Jeanice

Client

Thanks for another great Colella in Context, Vince. You are helping all of us by taking the time to write your thoughtful column.

Anonymous

Attorney

Attorney David Moss was referred to me after my car accident, I really did not know what to expect. I met with him and he explained the process well. His office helped me get compensation for missing work because of the accident. He was able to get compensation for my caregiver. He also was able to get all my medical bills from the accident paid by the insurance company. And finally he was able to get me much more from the insurance company than their first offer. He and his staff are professionals. I highly recommend Moss & Colella Law Firm. The other law firms say “they will fight for you”, no Attorney Moss will fight for you. Give his office a call and let them handle your case.

Dana Darby

Client

I was referred to Moss & Colella PC after the accident I was in. I could not have made a better choice. From the initial conversation I had with Mr. Moss about taking legal action, to the day I received my settlement, Mr. Moss and his team worked diligently and were adamant about getting what was deserved, keeping me informed each step of the way. What I respect the most about this firm is they are straight up with you about what is going on and what the best options are for you. Thank you to David, Ryan, Kelly, Janice and anyone else who had a part in getting this done.

Dame Mitchell

Client

Best choice I ever made going with Moss & Colella. Vince and Wendy were always there for me from start to finish I love you guys and your firm. I highly recommend this firm. Vince and Wendy are smart, sharp and caring people. God bless you guys and your firm thanks for everything

John Bahoura

Client

I was referred to David and I could never be happier!! I had NO Idea how my case would go or if I even had a case.  David was so STRAIGHT UP with me with the process and how things may go and I can honestly say I appreciated that the MOST. The entire staff made me feel so comfortable, they took care of business! I really appreciate you David!!

Breeana Coe

Client

Attorney David Moss, Ryan, and their assistant Kelly were all AMAZING. They were incredible understanding and patient with me and my family. It was like they knew EVERYTHING  we were going through. They were all right by our side going though and explaining every detail. When this ordeal started I ask someone if they knew of a pit bull that would be able to help us. I am so so glad I was referred to Attorney David Moss.

Thomas Hale

Client

I am very pleased with my experience with Moss & Colella, P.C.  The professionalism, and keeping you informed about every detail that took place were outstanding I could not have picked no one better to handle my case I would give them the highest grade that you possibly could give an attorneys office I am very satisfied with how my case was handled

Earl Moore

Client

The firm of Moss & Colella was wonderful they kept me and my family well informed and constantly gave updates in our challenging legal matter. Kept their word and didn't promise anything they couldn't deliver. I would highly recommend this firm for their personal service and depth of legal knowledge which was a win for my family and helped me feel at ease during a tragic time. Thank you. David Moss Great job. Have a great future. Highly recommended law firm

George Baird

Client

The best staff and always on top of everything. They stay in contact with updates and work hard and fast to hep you in every way. Thanks to all that worked on my case love you all.

Brian L

Client

David Moss and the Moss &  Colella team were awesome! I would recommend them to anyone

Lisette Montry

Client

This is a Top-notch Firm.. They explained my options every step of the way. I would recommend them to my closest family and friends.

Greg Sawmiller

Client

Excellent service very professional fully satisfied

Sterling Crutcher

Client

My experience with this law firm has been excellent. They work hard around-the-clock to solve your situation. I was suggest anyone that needed a lawyer whatever situation to contact them.

Deanne Freenan

Client

Free Case Evaluation

Rectangle

About the Firm

The attorneys of Moss & Colella have carefully chosen their career paths to fight for those that have suffered from injury and wrongful death. We believe every citizen should have the right to hire the best lawyer who will actively advocate for their case.

David Moss and Vince Colella have over 60 collective years of personal injury trial experience that provides you a level of legal services and success unmatched by other firms. By working together, we have the ability to find creative, effective, and efficient solutions to even the most complex cases. No matter what situation you face, we will help you get through it.

CTA Section

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.

Contact Us

Contact Us

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Ellipse Rectangle